Fix a Weak AI Prompt by Diagnosing Its Missing Role, Context and Format

Paste a prompt you wrote and get a diagnosis table of what is missing, a rewritten ready-to-copy version, and a one-line reason for each change.

Prompt

Prompt
You are a prompt engineer who rewrites everyday prompts so AI chat tools give useful answers on the first try.

I will paste a prompt I wrote right after this message. Diagnose what it is missing, then rewrite it.

Rules:
1. Check it against five parts: role, context (who it is for and why), task, constraints (length, tone, what to avoid), and output format. Mark each as Present, Weak or Missing.
2. If the rewrite needs facts only I know (audience, purpose, length, deadline), ask me up to 3 short numbered questions in one message and wait for my answers. If the prompt is already clear enough, skip the questions.
3. Keep my original goal. Do not add tasks I did not ask for.
4. Keep the rewrite under 150 words and make every constraint checkable (a number, a limit or a named format), not vague words like "good" or "detailed".
5. Do not put invented facts, statistics, quotes or credentials into the rewritten prompt.

Output format:## Diagnosis
Table with columns: Part | Status | What is wrong## Rewritten prompt
In a code block, ready to copy.## Why each change
Numbered list, one line per change, each tied to a row in the table.

End with one line naming any assumption you made or a detail I should still add.

Example output

Example for: the pasted prompt "write me a post about our new app" from a small-business owner launching a budgeting app called Tallybook on LinkedIn; answers given: audience is freelancers, goal is beta sign-ups, about 150 words.

Diagnosis

PartStatusWhat is wrong
RoleMissingNo voice or expertise given, so the model writes like a generic ad.
ContextMissingNo audience, platform or reason for the post.
TaskWeak"A post" could be a tweet, blog or press release.
ConstraintsMissingNo length, tone or things to avoid.
Output formatMissingNo structure, so you get one long block of text.

Rewritten prompt

Act as a LinkedIn copywriter who writes for freelancers.

Write a LinkedIn post announcing Tallybook, a budgeting app for freelancers with irregular income. The goal is to get people to join the free beta.

Key facts: it sorts income by client, sets aside a tax percentage from each payment, and shows how many weeks of expenses you have covered.

Rules:
- 120-160 words.
- Open with a one-line problem freelancers recognise, not with the app name.
- Plain, friendly tone; no hashtags in the body, max 3 at the end.
- No made-up user numbers or testimonials.

Output format: hook line, 3 short paragraphs, one call to action with the link placeholder removed (I will add the link), then hashtags.

Why each change

  1. Added a copywriter role so the tone fits LinkedIn instead of a sales brochure (Role).
  2. Named the audience and the beta goal so the post has a clear purpose (Context).
  3. Specified "LinkedIn post" and listed three real features so the model has facts to work with (Task).
  4. Set a word range, banned invented testimonials and capped hashtags so the result is easy to check (Constraints).
  5. Defined hook, three paragraphs and a call to action so the post is scannable (Output format).

Assumption: I used the three features you mentioned; add your beta deadline if there is one, since urgency usually lifts sign-ups.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • The five-part checklist with Present, Weak or Missing makes gaps visible instead of just handing you a rewrite.
  • Requiring checkable constraints swaps vague words like "detailed" for numbers and formats the model can actually follow.
  • Tying each change to a table row teaches you the pattern, so your next prompt starts stronger.

Use when ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini keeps giving you generic answers. Have your original prompt ready to paste, plus a rough idea of who the result is for and how long it should be.

Common edits

  • Ask for two rewrites: a short version and a detailed version, so you can compare results.
  • Raise the 150-word cap for complex jobs like research or coding prompts.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Personal & Life