Choose Between ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini for Your Specific Task

Get a side-by-side table comparing ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini for your task and budget, plus a pick, a backup, a starter prompt and what to check.

You getTask summary, comparison table and recommendation and backup

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a practical AI tools advisor who has compared ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini on everyday work.

Help me choose the right AI chat tool and features for a task I want done. Before recommending anything, ask me these questions in one message and wait for my answers:
1. What is the task, and what does a finished result look like?
2. What will I give the AI (text, files, images, spreadsheets, links), and roughly how much?
3. What is my budget: free only, one paid plan, or a work account?
4. Any limits, such as privacy rules, devices or language?

Rules:
- Compare only the features my task needs; skip the rest.
- For each tool, say whether each needed feature is on the free plan, a paid plan, or unclear.
- Mark any detail you are not sure is current with "(check)", because plans, limits and features change often.
- Recommend one tool and one backup, with reasons tied to my answers, not general reputation.
- Write a starter prompt I can paste into the recommended tool.

Output format:
1. Task summary (2 lines)
2. Comparison table: Feature needed | ChatGPT | Claude | Gemini | Free or paid
3. Recommendation and backup (3-4 bullets)
4. Starter prompt
5. What to check before paying (3 bullets)

End with one line on what you assumed and what could change the pick.

Example output

Example for: a secondary school teacher who wants to turn 30-page PDF curriculum reports into summaries and quiz questions, free plans only, uses Google Docs at school.

1. Task summary

Summarize long PDF reports (about 30 pages each, 2-3 per week) into one-page notes, then write 10 multiple-choice quiz questions per report. Free plans only; output goes into Google Docs.

2. Comparison table

Feature neededChatGPTClaudeGeminiFree or paid
Upload a 30-page PDFYes, with daily upload limits (check)Yes, handles long documents well (check size cap)Yes, including from Google Drive (check)Free on all three, with limits
Accurate long summariesGoodStrong on long, dense textGoodFree
Quiz question writingStrongStrongStrongFree
Send output to Google DocsCopy and pasteCopy and pasteExport to Docs option (check)Free
Message limits for 3 reports/weekFree tier caps may slow you down (check)Free tier caps are fairly tight (check)Generally workable on free (check)Free
School data privacyReview training settingsReview training settingsSchool Workspace accounts may have different terms (check)Depends on account

3. Recommendation and backup

  • Pick: Gemini (free). Your files and documents already live in Google Drive and Docs, so you save copy-paste steps each week.
  • Backup: Claude (free). Use it when a report is very dense and the summary needs to stay close to the source wording.
  • Run one report through both in week one and keep whichever summary needs fewer fixes.
  • Do not upload anything with student names or grades until you confirm your school's AI policy.

4. Starter prompt

"I am attaching a curriculum report. First, write a one-page summary with five headings: purpose, key findings, changes for teachers, deadlines, open questions. Then write 10 multiple-choice questions for Year 10 students, four options each, with the correct answer marked and a one-line explanation. Quote the page number for each key finding."

5. What to check before paying

  • Current free-tier upload size and daily message limits on each tool's pricing page.
  • Whether your school account allows Gemini or blocks third-party AI tools.
  • Whether a paid plan actually removes the limit you hit, or just raises it.

Assumed: reports are text-based PDFs, not scanned images; scanned files or a stricter school privacy policy could change the pick.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking about task, inputs and budget first means the comparison is about your job, not a generic feature list.
  • The "(check)" rule flags details that may be outdated, so you verify limits before relying on them or paying.
  • A pick plus a backup and a ready starter prompt turns the comparison into something you can act on today.

Use before signing up for a paid plan or when unsure which assistant fits a job. Paste into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini and have your task, file types and budget ready to answer.

Common edits

  • Add Perplexity or Copilot as extra columns if you are considering them too.
  • Ask for a monthly cost estimate per tool if you are open to paid plans.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Personal & Life