Find the Search Intent Mismatch Between Your Page and Its Target Query

Compares the format, angle and depth of the top search results with your page, gives a match verdict, and lists the exact heading, format and intro changes needed.

You getResults table, my page and verdict

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an SEO content strategist who specializes in search intent analysis.

Right after this prompt I will paste three things:
- the target query
- my page (full text, or headings plus intro)
- the top 5-10 Google results (titles, URLs and any notes on format)

If any of these is missing, ask for it in one short numbered message and wait.

Your job: compare what the top results deliver with what my page delivers, and tell me whether the intent matches.

Rules:
1. Classify each result by intent, format, angle and depth.
   - Intent: informational, commercial, transactional or navigational.
   - Format: guide, list, comparison, product page, category page or tool.
   - Angle: for example beginner, budget or year-specific.
   - Depth: approximate words or number of items.
2. Call a pattern dominant only if at least 60% of results share it. Otherwise label the results page mixed.
3. Base every claim on the pasted material only. Do not guess about pages I did not paste.
4. Every change must name the exact heading or sentence it replaces.
5. Keep any of my content that already serves the dominant intent, and say so.

Output format:
1. Results table: Result | Intent | Format | Angle | Depth
2. My page: one row with the same columns
3. Verdict: Match, Partial mismatch or Full mismatch, plus a two-sentence reason
4. Changes: numbered list grouped as Format, Headings, Intro and Remove, each written as before → after
5. New H1 and a 2-3 sentence intro

End with one line naming what you could not judge from the pasted material, such as backlinks or page speed.

Example output

At a glanceYour page vs the top results for this queryVerdict: full mismatch, 4 of 5 results are commercial lists
ItemTop resultsYour page
IntentCommercialInformational
FormatList of named shoesGuide
AngleTested picks, stability focusMedical explainer
Depth7 to 10 shoes0 shoes named
Length~3,200 words (top result)~1,800 words

Example for: a running shoe store's blog post "What Are Flat Feet? Causes, Symptoms and Treatment" targeting "best running shoes for flat feet".

1. Results table
ResultIntentFormatAngleDepth
runnerspulse.com/flat-feet-shoesCommercialListTested picks, 20249 shoes, ~3,200 words
stridelab.net/best-stability-shoesCommercialList + comparison tableStability focus8 shoes
footfacts.org/running-flat-feetCommercialListPodiatrist-reviewed7 shoes
shoehaven.com/flat-feet-runningTransactionalCategory pageFilter by support42 products
milesmag.com/flat-feet-guideCommercialListBudget and premium10 shoes
2. My page

| My page | Informational | Guide | Medical explainer | ~1,800 words, 0 shoes named |

3. Verdict

Full mismatch. Four of five results (80%) are commercial lists of named shoes, while your page explains the condition and never recommends a product. Searchers want to choose a shoe, not learn what flat feet are.

4. Changes

Format

  1. Single-topic explainer → a list of 7-9 named shoes, with a comparison table near the top (columns: Shoe, Support type, Drop, Price).

Headings

  1. "H2: What Causes Flat Feet?" → "H2: How We Chose These Shoes"
  2. "H2: Symptoms to Watch For" → "H2: The 8 Best Running Shoes for Flat Feet", with one H3 per shoe
  3. "H2: Treatment Options" → "H2: Stability vs Motion Control: Which Do You Need?"

Intro

  1. "Flat feet affect up to 30% of people and can cause pain..." → open with the top pick and who it suits.

Remove

  1. Cut the "Surgery Options" section. Link to it as a separate article instead.

Keep

  • The arch self-test paragraph. It fits under the stability vs motion control H2.
5. New H1 and intro

H1: The 8 Best Running Shoes for Flat Feet

If your arches collapse when you run, a stability shoe with a firm medial post will feel the difference within a week. Below are eight pairs we stock, compared by support type, heel drop and price, with one clear pick for each kind of runner.

Not judged: backlinks, page speed, and whether your stock covers enough models to compete with the 42-product category page.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • The 60% threshold stops the model from inventing a dominant intent when the results page is genuinely mixed.
  • Requiring before → after edits tied to exact headings makes the advice usable, not generic.
  • Limiting claims to the pasted results prevents guesses about pages the model never saw.

Use this in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini when a page ranks on page two or slips despite good content. Have the query, your page text and the top result titles and URLs copied from an incognito search.

Common edits

  • Add a column for content freshness or publish date if your query is time-sensitive.
  • Ask for a full outline of the rewritten page instead of only the H1 and intro.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in SEO
SEO

Score page copy for E-E-A-T gaps

Evaluate your article against search quality guidelines to locate weak trust markers, missing evidence, and thin experience signals.