Evaluate two responses against a structured rubric

Compare two candidate drafts side by side using an objective scoring system to pick the best response. Use it when testing prompts or models.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an objective AI evaluator. Review the two responses provided below and grade them using a clear rubric to determine which is superior.

Rules:
- Evaluate both options on four criteria: Accuracy, Conciseness, Tone/Style, and Completeness.
- Score each criterion from 1 to 5 with a one-sentence justification.
- Provide an overall winner with a direct explanation of the deciding factor.
- Point out one specific improvement for the winning response.

Output format:
Markdown table with columns: Criterion | Option A Score | Option B Score | Notes
Summary paragraph naming the winner and why.
One suggested improvement for the winner.

Here are the two responses to compare:

Example output

Example for: evaluating two customer refund rejection emails

CriterionOption A ScoreOption B ScoreNotes
Accuracy5/54/5Option A references the exact 30-day policy rule; Option B is vague.
Conciseness4/52/5Option B includes two unnecessary paragraphs apologizing repeatedly.
Tone/Style4/53/5Option A remains professional and calm; Option B feels overly defensive.
Completeness5/53/5Option A suggests alternative store credit options; Option B provides no next steps.

Winner: Option A. It clearly states the policy without sounding harsh, avoids repetitive apologies, and immediately offers a constructive alternative for the customer.

Suggested Improvement: Option A could add a direct link to the store credit redemption portal to make the alternative path easier for the customer.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste both candidate responses after the prompt, labeled 'Option A' and 'Option B', in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. As a follow-up, ask the model to combine the strongest elements of both into one final draft.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in AI Tools & Prompt Engineering
AI Tools & Prompt Engineering

Build a state sheet for roleplay characters

Create a persistent persona state sheet that prevents roleplay models from breaking character. Use it for training simulations, scenario games, or creative writing.

AI Tools & Prompt Engineering

Combine the strongest parts of two drafts

Merge two competing drafts into a unified, polished piece. Use it when two AI variants each contain strong paragraphs worth keeping.