Establish strict rules to separate brainstorming from critique

Stop premature criticism from killing creative concepts with clear phased guidelines that keep ideation and evaluation apart.

You getCore Ground Rules, real-Time Facilitator Interventions and the Transition Ritual

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an executive meeting facilitator. Create an operating guide that strictly separates divergent idea generation from convergent evaluation during company workshops.

Rules:
- Provide clear psychological safety guidelines that eliminate instant criticism during ideation.
- Detail three verbal intervention phrases the facilitator can use immediately when someone critiques an early idea.
- Define a concrete transition mechanism that signals when ideation ends and evaluation begins.
- Establish objective criteria for the critique phase to stop subjective dismissals.

Output format:
- Core Ground Rules (3 distinct rules for the room)
- Real-Time Facilitator Interventions (3 direct scripts to stop critique)
- The Transition Ritual (step-by-step handover from green light to red light)
- Objective Evaluation Matrix (table with columns: Filter, Evaluation Question, Scoring Scale)
- Closing Facilitator Checklist

Example output

Core Ground Rules
  1. Defer All Judgement: No evaluations, sighs, or critiques—positive or negative—are permitted during Phase 1. Even praise can narrow exploration.
  2. Quantity Over Quality: The goal of ideation is raw volume. Incomplete, unusual, and ambitious suggestions are intentionally welcomed.
  3. Build, Do Not Block: Participants may only contribute additions using the phrase "Yes, and..." rather than "Yes, but..."
Real-Time Facilitator Interventions
  • When someone points out a technical hurdle: "Hold that thought. We are capturing possibilities right now, not technical barriers. I am noting that risk for our review phase in twenty minutes."
  • When someone scoffs or dismisses an idea: "Pause. Every concept stays on the board for now. Let us see what other ideas this sparks before we filter anything."
  • When someone asks 'How would that work?': "We will test mechanics in step two. For now, what else does that idea lead to?"
The Transition Ritual
  1. Call an explicit 3-minute physical break. Instruct everyone to stand up, stretch, and step away from the board.
  2. Switch room lighting or board background color to signal an operating mode shift.
  3. Announce formally: "Idea generation is now closed. We are now shifting into analytical critique. Our standard is no longer novelty; our standard is practical feasibility."
Objective Evaluation Matrix

| Filter | Evaluation Question | Scoring Scale |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | |
| Impact | Does this directly solve the core customer bottleneck? | 1 (Marginal) to 5 (Transformative) |
| Effort | Can our current engineering team build this within six weeks? | 1 (Months) to 5 (Days) |
| Alignment | Does this comply with our published Q3 company priorities? | Pass / Fail |

Closing Facilitator Checklist
  • Verify all submitted ideas were transcribed before starting the critique.
  • Ensure low-scoring ideas are archived rather than deleted to preserve future insights.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste this prompt as-is into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. As a helpful follow-up, ask the model to provide a brief 2-minute slide intro summarizing the rules to project at the start of your meeting.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Meetings & Notes