Create a weighted multi-criteria decision matrix

Compare complex options objectively by generating clear evaluation criteria, weights, and a scoring rubric.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an analytical decision strategist. You will build a weighted decision matrix to help me choose between competing options without bias.
First, ask me 3 short numbered questions in one message and wait for my response:
1. What are the competing options you need to choose between?
2. What are your non-negotiable requirements versus your flexible preferences?
3. What timeline, financial, or organizational constraints govern this decision?
After I answer, deliver:
- Weighted Criteria Breakdown (criteria list, percentage weights summing to 100%, and scoring rationale)
- Scoring Matrix (Markdown table comparing each option on a 1-5 scale across all criteria, including total weighted scores)
- Sensitivity Analysis (which single score shift could overturn the winner)
- Next Verification Step (one real-world fact to verify before executing)

Example output

Example for: choosing between three office space lease options

Weighted Criteria Breakdown

  • Total Cost (35%): Monthly rent plus estimated build-out and operating fees.
  • Commute Accessibility (25%): Proximity to major transit hubs for the current employee footprint.
  • Lease Flexibility (20%): Sublease clauses, break options, and expansion terms.
  • Move-In Readiness (20%): Immediate availability without requiring extensive construction.
    Total Weight: 100%

Scoring Matrix (Scale 1-5, where 5 is best)

Criteria (Weight)Downtown TowerSuburb Business ParkMidtown Loft
Total Cost (35%)2 (0.70)5 (1.75)3 (1.05)
Commute Accessibility (25%)5 (1.25)2 (0.50)4 (1.00)
Lease Flexibility (20%)2 (0.40)4 (0.80)4 (0.80)
Move-In Readiness (20%)4 (0.80)3 (0.60)2 (0.40)
Total Weighted Score3.153.653.25

Sensitivity Analysis
Suburb Business Park wins primarily due to rent savings. However, if the commute penalty drives estimated employee attrition above 10%, the cost of hiring easily wipes out the lease savings. If Commute Accessibility rises to 40%, Total Cost falls to 25%, Lease Flexibility falls to 15%, and Move-In Readiness stays at 20%, Downtown Tower becomes the top option with a score of 3.60, ahead of Suburb Business Park at 3.25 and Midtown Loft at 3.35.

Next Verification Step
Survey the core team's residential transit zones to confirm whether the Suburb Business Park adds more than 25 minutes to the average daily round-trip commute.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Run this prompt in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. The model will respond with 3 quick questions; reply with your options and constraints in simple bullet points. Follow up by asking how the outcome changes if your budget drops by 20%.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Critical Thinking & Decisions
Critical Thinking & Decisions

Audit a preferred choice for cognitive biases

Identify subconscious biases steering you toward a particular option. Use this audit when a high-stakes decision feels too obvious or emotionally charged.