Compare credit card rewards with your actual spending

Run real dollar calculations between two credit card offers using your monthly spending habits and annual fees. Use before applying for a new card.

You getNet Value Breakdown Table, break-Even Analysis and clear Verdict

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an analytical credit card and rewards analyst. Calculate and compare the net financial return of two credit cards based on my real spending patterns.

- Subtract annual fees from gross rewards to calculate net annual cash value for Year 1 and Year 2.
- Value standard cash back at 1 cent per point unless stated otherwise; highlight redemption traps.
- Disregard promotional perks that require unnatural spending.
- Provide general financial information only, not credit or lending advice; carrying a balance negates rewards due to high interest rates.

Output format:
1. Net Value Breakdown Table (Columns: Metric, Card A, Card B)
2. Break-Even Analysis (Exact monthly spend needed to justify any annual fee)
3. Clear Verdict (Which card wins mathematically for this spending profile)

My monthly spending and the two cards are below:

Example output

Example for: $400 groceries, $200 dining, $300 all other spend. Comparing Card A (No fee 2% flat card) vs. Card B ($95 fee, 6% groceries up to $6k, 3% dining, 1% other)

1. Net Value Breakdown Table
MetricCard A (Flat 2% No-Fee)Card B ($95 Annual Fee Tiered)
Monthly Grocery Reward$8.00 (2%)$24.00 (6%)
Monthly Dining Reward$4.00 (2%)$6.00 (3%)
Monthly Base Spend Reward$6.00 (2%)$3.00 (1%)
Total Gross Monthly Earnings$18.00$33.00
Gross Annual Rewards$216.00$396.00
Annual Fee$0.00-$95.00
Net Year 1 Value (No bonus)$216.00$301.00
Net Year 2+ Ongoing Value$216.00$301.00
2. Break-Even Analysis
  • To clear the $95 fee on Card B relative to a baseline 2% card, you need Card B's grocery bonus (4% incremental over 2%) to produce at least $95.
  • Break-Even Formula: $95 / 0.04 = $2,375 annual grocery spending ($198 per month).
  • Because your monthly grocery spending is $400 ($4,800/year), you easily exceed the break-even threshold by $202 per month.
3. Clear Verdict

Winner: Card B. Even after accounting for the $95 annual fee, your heavy grocery allocation generates $85 more in net cash value each year compared to the flat 2% card.

Note: If you ever carry an unpaid monthly balance, interest charges will instantly exceed these cash back gains. Pay the statement balance in full every billing cycle.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste this prompt into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini, then add your average monthly spending across categories (like groceries, dining, travel) and the names or fees of the two cards you are comparing.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Personal Finance