Compare an Auto Lease Offer Against Buying New or Used

Get a structured five-year cost comparison across leasing, buying new, and buying used, factoring in depreciation, financing, insurance, and exit fees.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an objective auto finance analyst. Compare an auto lease offer against purchasing the vehicle new and buying a 3-year-old used model over a 5-year timeline.

First, ask me 3 numbered questions and wait for my response:
1. Vehicle make, model, trim, and MSRP.
2. Lease terms offered (monthly payment, down payment, lease duration, annual mileage limit, and dealer fees).
3. Purchase terms you are considering (available cash down, expected loan interest rate, and loan term in months).

Rules:
- Format a 5-year total-cost comparison table with 3 columns: Lease (renewed or bought out at term), Buy New (financed), and Buy Used (financed).
- Break down all cost rows: Upfront Costs, Total Monthly Payments, Estimated Insurance Difference, Estimated Maintenance and Repairs, Disposition/Acquisition Fees, and Estimated Vehicle Equity at Year 5.
- Calculate the Net 5-Year Out-of-Pocket Cost (total spent minus end equity).
- Keep all estimates conservative and state depreciation rates explicitly.

Output format:
### 5-Year Ownership Cost Comparison (Table)
### Cost Driver Breakdown (3 concise bullets)
### Recommendation & Break-Even Insight (plain explanation)

Note: This calculation is for educational planning only and does not constitute formal financial advice; consult a qualified financial planner or tax advisor for large asset decisions.

Example output

Example for: a driver comparing a 36-month lease on a $36,000 Toyota RAV4 against buying it new at 5.9% APR or buying a 2021 model for $24,000 at 6.9% APR.

5-Year Ownership Cost Comparison
Cost ComponentLease (36 mo + 24 mo 2nd Lease)Buy New ($36,000 MSRP, 60 mo)Buy Used ($24,000, 48 mo)
Upfront Cash / Down Payment$2,500$3,500$2,500
Total Monthly Payments (60 mo)$26,400 ($440/mo avg)$37,800 ($630/mo)$25,440 ($530/mo x 48, $0 x 12)
Estimated Insurance Total$7,800$7,200$6,300
Maintenance & Tires$1,200$3,100$4,800
Acquisition / Disposition Fees$1,045$0$0
Gross 5-Year Spend$38,945$51,600$39,040
Less: Residual Equity at Year 5$0-$16,200 (45% residual)-$11,500 (residual value)
Net 5-Year Cost$38,945$35,400$27,540
Cost Driver Breakdown
  • Equity Erosion: The lease has zero residual equity at month 60, turning every dollar spent into a permanent sunk cost.
  • Financing vs. Depreciation: Buying new carries high early depreciation ($19,800 lost value over 5 years), but retains $16,200 in trade-in value, beating the continuous lease cycle by $3,545.
  • Maintenance Trade-Off: The used vehicle incurs $3,600 more in repairs and tires than the leased car, but saves over $11,400 in net purchase and insurance costs.
Recommendation & Break-Even Insight

Buying the 3-year-old used vehicle delivers the lowest 5-year cost by $7,860 compared to buying new and by $11,405 compared to continuous leasing. The new car purchase overtakes the lease financially at month 44 once the loan balance dips below market trade-in value.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Forces a standardized 5-year horizon so leases and loans can be evaluated on identical timelines.
  • Accounts for retained vehicle equity at Year 5, preventing leases from falsely appearing cheaper.
  • Isolates maintenance and dealer fees so all secondary ownership costs are visible upfront.

Use this prompt in ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini when shopping for a car. Paste your dealer quote sheet or loan estimates after answering the three intake questions.

Common edits

  • Change the timeline from 5 years to 3 years to match a single standard lease cycle without rolling over.
  • Add a business use row to factor in annual mileage deductions or tax write-offs for self-employed drivers.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Personal Finance