Build a project intake scoring rubric for requests

Establish an objective scoring matrix to evaluate incoming project requests and prevent urgent ad-hoc demands from crowding out strategic priorities.

You getScoring Dimensions and Definitions, evaluation Rubric Matrix and triage Action Thresholds

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an enterprise PMO director. Create a repeatable project intake scoring rubric that balances immediate business pain with long-term strategy.

Rules:
- Define five distinct scoring dimensions that cover strategic fit, financial value, operational urgency, technical risk, and resource demand.
- Use a standard 1 to 5 scale for each dimension with plain, unambiguous criteria for minimum (1) and maximum (5) scores.
- Include a weighting formula that totals 100% to produce a single final score from 100 to 500 points.
- Establish definitive threshold bands showing what gets immediate kickoff, scheduled for quarterly planning, or declined.

Output format:
1. Scoring Dimensions and Definitions
2. Evaluation Rubric Matrix (table with columns: Dimension, Weight %, Score 1 Definition, Score 3 Definition, Score 5 Definition)
3. Triage Action Thresholds (Score Band, Priority Status, Next PMO Action)
4. Fast-Track Exception Criteria (3 clear rules for bypassing the queue without breaking governance)

Example output

1. Scoring Dimensions and Definitions
  • Strategic Alignment (30%): Direct connection to stated annual corporate OKRs.
  • Business Impact & ROI (25%): Revenue upside, cost reduction, or verified efficiency gains.
  • Customer & Operational Urgency (15%): Risk of operational outage or immediate client churn.
  • Technical Feasibility & Risk (15%): Architecture readiness and security implications.
  • Resource Requirement (15%): Bandwidth and specialization level demanded from core teams.
2. Evaluation Rubric Matrix
DimensionWeight %Score 1 DefinitionScore 3 DefinitionScore 5 Definition
Strategic Alignment30%Off-strategy; solves an isolated departmental preference.Supports a secondary goal or indirectly aids an OKR.Direct dependency for a tier-1 company milestone.
Business Impact25%Marginal or unquantified efficiency improvement.Measured cost savings between $50k-$150k annually.High revenue impact ($250k+) or mandatory compliance mandate.
Urgency15%Can wait 6+ months with zero revenue or operational penalty.Process pain exists; temporary workaround functions.Regulatory deadline or active, severe customer churn driver.
Technical Risk15%Requires unproven technology or complex structural rework.Standard integration with known internal components.Turnkey tool or well-understood configuration task.
Resource Demand15%Requires 2+ specialized teams for 8+ weeks.Requires 1 cross-functional team for 2-4 weeks.Self-contained within requesting team or minimal PMO effort.
3. Triage Action Thresholds
  • 400 - 500 (Priority Tier 1): Immediate approval. Assigned to the active sprint or current delivery quarter.
  • 300 - 399 (Priority Tier 2): Queued for the next quarterly capacity planning review.
  • Below 300 (Decline / Backlog): Request returned to submitter with specific improvement feedback.
4. Fast-Track Exception Criteria
  1. Active critical security vulnerability flagged by compliance.
  2. External regulatory change with a legally mandated delivery date.
  3. Executive Committee written mandate addressing an immediate business continuity risk.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Copy and run this directly in Claude, ChatGPT, or Gemini. As a follow-up, ask the model to test the rubric against three hypothetical project requests from sales, IT, and customer support.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in Project Management
Project Management

Audit a RACI chart for split accountability

Identify dangerous governance flaws, duplicate owners, and delivery bottlenecks in an existing RACI matrix. Use this before launching high-stakes projects.

Project Management

Build a RACI matrix from deliverables

Assign clear operational roles across all major project workstreams. Use to eliminate delivery confusion and establish single-point task accountability.

Project Management

Create a project risk trigger matrix

Define measurable threshold indicators and immediate response owners before risks become active problems. Use it during project kickoff or sprint planning.