Appeal a false item not as described claim

Draft a calm, evidence-based dispute appeal to remove an unjust defect or strike against your seller account.

You getAppeal Subject Line, formal Appeal Body and evidence Checklist

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an e-commerce marketplace operations specialist. Review the dispute details below and write a formal, concise appeal to marketplace seller support.

- State the exact order and claim facts without emotional language.
- Contrast the buyer complaint directly against the original listing title, bullet points, or photos.
- Reference tracking timestamps, delivery scans, or packing slips where relevant.
- State the exact remedy requested, such as removing the defect strike or closing the claim in the seller's favor.
- Note that this message provides operational guidance and does not constitute formal legal representation.

Output format:
1. Appeal Subject Line
2. Formal Appeal Body (under 250 words)
3. Evidence Checklist (bullet list of attachments to include)

The dispute details and listing text are below:

Example output

Example for: an eBay buyer claiming a vintage wool sweater was described as synthetic blend

  1. Appeal Subject Line
    Appeal Request: Defect Removal for Order 14-09821-44321 (Incorrect INAD Claim)
  2. Formal Appeal Body
    Dear Marketplace Support Team,

We request the removal of an Item Not As Described (INAD) defect recorded for Order 14-09821-44321, delivered on October 12.

The buyer opened a return claiming the item was "not acrylic as expected." However, the listing title explicitly states "100% Merino Wool Fisherman Sweater," and the item specifics list the material as 100% Wool. A close-up photograph of the manufacturer's care tag showing 100% Merino Wool was uploaded as photo 4 in the original listing.

The item delivered matches the listing description and photographs in every specification. The return reason selected does not reflect any listing discrepancy or seller error.

Because the item precisely matches the listing details, we ask that you close this claim without fault and remove the associated defect from our seller performance metrics.

Thank you for reviewing the documentation.

  1. Evidence Checklist
  • Screenshot of original listing title and Item Specifics section highlighting material.
  • Photo 4 from original listing displaying the garment fiber content tag.
  • Carrier delivery confirmation scan showing successful delivery on October 12.
Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Paste your order details, buyer comments, and listing excerpt into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini right after the prompt. As a follow-up, ask the model to shorten the appeal if the platform has a strict character limit.

Make it repeatable

Keep using this prompt without pasting it in every time.

Keep exploring

More in E-commerce
E-commerce

Write holiday gift bundle product copy

Turn standard multi-item listings into appealing, gift-ready holiday packages. Perfect for Q4 ecommerce merchandising and seasonal promotions.