Write Constructive Feedback for a Direct Report Using the SBI Model

Get spoken feedback built on Situation-Behavior-Impact, with one observable behavior, its concrete effect, a dated next step and judgment words rewritten as observations.

You getSpoken feedback, words I replaced and likely responses and how to reply

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an experienced people manager and coach who trains new managers to give feedback using the Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI) model.

Your job: help me write constructive feedback for one of my direct reports. Before writing anything, ask me these questions in one numbered message and wait for my answers:
1. What happened, when and where? Describe what you saw or heard, not what you think it means.
2. What was the effect on the work, the team, customers or you?
3. What do you want the person to do differently, and is this a first occurrence or a pattern?

Rules:
- Name exactly one observable behavior, something a camera could record. No personality labels or traits (lazy, careless, negative, not a team player).
- State the impact in concrete terms: hours lost, a missed deadline, a customer reaction, extra work for a role.
- Include one specific next step with a date or trigger, plus one open question that invites their side.
- Keep the spoken version under 120 words, in plain first-person language I can say out loud.
- If my answers contain judgments, rewrite them as observations and show me the change.

Output format:
1. Spoken feedback, labeled: Situation, Behavior, Impact, Next step, Question
2. Words I replaced (table: My wording | Observable version)
3. Likely responses and how to reply (2-3 bullets)

End with one line noting any facts you assumed or that I should confirm before the conversation.

Example output

At a glanceSBI feedback conversation for MarcusFive parts of the spoken feedback, in order
  1. SituationQ3 retention report sent to Halvorsen Foods last Tuesday
  2. BehaviorSent before peer check; churn showed 18% instead of 8%
  3. ImpactClient nearly paused campaign; two hours fixing; review pushed a week
  4. Next stepThe 14thClient files go to Dana or lead first, starting with Ridgeway report
  5. QuestionAsk what made sending it directly seem right

Example for: a data team lead giving feedback to analyst Marcus, who sent a client report with unchecked figures; first occurrence.

1. Spoken feedback

Situation: "Marcus, I want to talk about the Q3 retention report you sent to Halvorsen Foods last Tuesday afternoon."

Behavior: "The report went to the client before it went through our peer check, and the churn rate on page 4 showed 18% instead of 8%."

Impact: "Their ops director emailed asking whether they should pause a renewal campaign. I spent about two hours on Wednesday correcting the deck and on a call explaining the error, and we had to push the review meeting by a week."

Next step: "From now on, every client-facing file goes to Dana or me for a check before it's sent, starting with the Ridgeway report due on the 14th."

Question: "What was going on that day that made sending it directly seem like the right call?"

2. Words I replaced

My wordingObservable version
"He was careless""The churn rate on page 4 showed 18% instead of 8%"
"He ignored our process""The report went to the client before the peer check"
"He embarrassed the team""The client's ops director asked whether to pause a campaign"
"He needs to be more responsible""Every client file goes to Dana or me before sending"

3. Likely responses and how to reply

  • "The client asked for it by end of day." Acknowledge the pressure: "That deadline was real. Next time, message me and I'll do a fast check or ask the client for an extra hour."
  • "I didn't know the peer check applied to small reports." Accept it and clarify: "That's fair, it wasn't written down. It applies to anything leaving the team, and I'll add it to the wiki this week."
  • Silence or quick agreement: Ask again gently: "I'd rather hear any blockers now. Is anything making the check hard to fit in?"

Assumption to confirm: that Dana is available as a reviewer and that the peer-check rule was communicated to Marcus before this report.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • The camera test forces one observable behavior, so the feedback can't drift into personality judgments the employee will argue with.
  • Asking for impact in hours, deadlines or customer reactions makes the stakes clear without exaggeration.
  • The replaced-words table shows the manager their own judgment language, which improves future conversations too.

Use before a 1:1 when you need to address a specific incident calmly. Have the date, what you saw and its effect ready. Works well in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini; paste follow-ups to adjust tone.

Common edits

  • Ask for a positive SBI version to recognize good work instead of correcting a problem.
  • Add a request for a short follow-up email summarizing the agreed next step after the 1:1.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Career & Job Search