Write a Refund or Return Denial Email That Keeps the Customer

Get a clear, polite denial email that explains the policy reason in plain words, offers an approved alternative, and includes a short chat version and escalation-risk note.

You getSubject line, email reply and internal note

Prompt

Prompt
You are a senior customer support lead who writes refund and return replies that hold the line on policy without losing the customer.

Your job: write a reply denying a refund or return request. Before writing, ask me these questions in one numbered message and wait for my answers:
1. What does the relevant policy say? Paste the exact wording if you have it.
2. What are the order details: product, order date, request date, price, and the customer's stated reason?
3. What can the team actually offer instead (store credit, exchange, repair, partial refund, discount)? List only what is approved.
4. Paste the customer's message or describe their tone.

Rules:
- State the decision within the first two sentences.
- Explain the reason in plain words, naming the specific policy point and the date or condition that applies.
- Offer at least one alternative from my approved list only; never promise anything I did not approve.
- No blame, use "unfortunately" at most once, and avoid "per our policy".
- Keep the email under 170 words and end with one clear next step for the customer.

Output format:
- Subject line
- Email reply
- Internal note: escalation risk (low, medium or high) and why, in one line
- Two-sentence version for chat or SMS

If any policy detail or approved alternative is missing, say so instead of guessing.

Example output

At a glanceReturn denial at a glanceWhy the return was declined and what was offered instead
Days since delivery
41 days
Return policy allows 30 days
Warranty fix
Free repair
Or replacement, shipping both ways included
Upgrade discount
20% off
Vortex 900 with stronger motor
Escalation risk
Medium
Warranty fix addresses the real problem

Example for: a home goods store denying a return on a used blender requested 41 days after delivery under a 30-day policy.

Subject line: Your Vortex 600 blender return request – and how we can help

Email reply:

Hi Dana,

Thanks for reaching out about your Vortex 600 blender. We can't accept a return on this order, but we do want to get you a blender that works for you.

Here's why: our return window is 30 days from delivery, and items need to be unused. Your blender arrived on March 4, and your request came in on April 14, which is 41 days later. It has also been used, so it no longer qualifies for a return.

You mentioned the motor stalls on frozen fruit. That is covered by the 1-year manufacturer warranty, so we can arrange a free repair or replacement at no cost to you, including shipping both ways. If you'd rather try a different model, we can also give you 20% off our Vortex 900, which has a stronger motor for frozen blends.

Just reply with "repair" or "upgrade" and I'll set it up today.

Warm regards,
Priya Nandakumar
Kettle & Crumb Home Support

Internal note: Escalation risk: medium. The customer is frustrated about the stalling motor, but a free warranty fix addresses the real problem.

Chat/SMS version:
Hi Dana, we can't take a return on your blender since it's past our 30-day window and has been used. The stalling motor is covered by warranty, so reply "repair" for a free fix or "upgrade" for 20% off the Vortex 900.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking for the exact policy and approved alternatives first stops the model from inventing offers your team can't deliver.
  • Putting the decision in the first two sentences avoids false hope and the angry follow-up it causes.
  • The escalation-risk note and chat version give agents a ready plan for the next channel or reply.

Use when you must say no to a refund or return but want to keep the customer. Have the policy text, order dates, and your approved alternatives ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini.

Common edits

  • Change the tone to match your brand voice, such as more casual for a DTC brand or more formal for B2B.
  • Ask for three versions with different alternatives so you can pick the one that fits the customer best.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Customer Support