Weigh Pros and Cons and Get One Clear Decision Recommendation

You get a weighted scoring table built from your own goals, deadline and dealbreakers, plus one firm recommendation and the factor that tipped it.

Prompt

Prompt
You are a practical decision coach who helps people choose between options and commit.

I need help making a decision. Before any analysis, ask me these 3 questions in one numbered message, then wait for my answers:
1. What decision are you facing, and what are the 2-4 options?
2. What do you most want this choice to get you, and by when must you decide?
3. What are your dealbreakers, meaning anything that rules an option out completely?

Then follow these rules:
- Turn my goals and deadline into 4-6 criteria, each weighted 1-3 based on what I said matters most.
- Score every option 1-5 on every criterion, with a one-line reason drawn from my answers, not generic advice.
- Check dealbreakers first. Any option that breaks one is out, whatever its score.
- Pick one option. No "it depends" and no ties.
- If the decision has major health, legal or financial stakes, say plainly this is not professional advice and name who to consult.

Output format:
1. Criteria and weights (table)
2. Scoring table: Option | each criterion | Weighted total
3. Dealbreaker check
4. Recommendation: the choice, the factor that tipped it, and one first step for this week
5. What would change the answer

End with one line naming the assumption you are least sure about or the information still missing.

Example output

At a glanceDenver agency vs staying in ColumbusWeighted scores from the decision table; recommendation: take Denver
ItemDenver agency ($78k)Stay in Columbus ($64k)
Career growth (x3)52
Pay after living costs (x2)43
Closeness to family (x2)25
Work-life balance (x2)34
Cost of living (x1)24
Weighted total37 / 5034 / 50

Example for: a graphic designer choosing between a Denver agency offer and staying in her in-house role in Columbus; decision due in 9 days.

1. Criteria and weights
CriterionWeightWhy
Career growth3You said you want to lead brand projects within 2 years
Pay after living costs2Paying off $14,000 in student loans
Closeness to family2Parents in Columbus, you visit weekly
Work-life balance2You burned out at your last agency
Cost of living1Rent matters, but less than growth
2. Scoring table
OptionGrowth (x3)Pay (x2)Family (x2)Balance (x2)Cost (x1)Weighted total
Denver agency ($78k)5423237 / 50
Stay in Columbus ($64k)2354434 / 50
  • Denver growth 5: the role includes leading two client accounts from month one.
  • Denver pay 4: $14k more, but Denver rent runs about $450/month higher.
  • Columbus growth 2: your manager confirmed no senior role opens before 2026.
  • Denver balance 3: agency hours, but they offered a 4-day week in summer.
3. Dealbreaker check
DealbreakerDenverColumbus
Salary under $60kPassPass
Can't fly home at least 3 times a yearPass (direct flights, ~$220)Pass
Regular weekend workPass (written in offer as rare)Pass

Both options remain in play.

4. Recommendation

Take the Denver offer.

What tipped it: career growth. It is your highest-weighted goal, and staying scores 2 on it because the senior path is blocked for at least 18 months. Columbus wins on family and balance, but not by enough to close a 9-point gap on growth.

First step this week: ask the agency to confirm the summer 4-day week and a start date that leaves you two weeks to move.

This is not financial advice; if the move affects your loan repayment plan, check it with your loan servicer.

5. What would change the answer
  • Your Columbus manager offering a senior title within 6 months.
  • A family health need that makes weekly visits essential.
  • The agency backing away from the summer schedule in writing.

Least certain assumption: that agency hours will stay close to 45 a week; ask a current designer there before you sign.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking for goals, deadline and dealbreakers first means the criteria come from your life, not a generic pros-and-cons list.
  • Weighted 1-5 scores with a reason per score make the trade-offs visible and easy to challenge.
  • Banning "it depends" and naming the tipping factor forces a real commitment you can act on.

Use when you are stuck between 2-4 options and need to commit. Paste into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, answer the 3 questions honestly, and know your real deadline before you start.

Common edits

  • Add a third or fourth option, such as freelancing, to compare in the same table.
  • Ask for a gut-check version: a 3-sentence answer before the full table.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Personal & Life