Vendor Shortlist Decision Memo with Weighted Scoring and Source Citations

Guides a source-backed evaluation of software or service vendors against weighted criteria. Ends with a decision memo covering risks, open questions, and verification steps before purchase.

You get: Decision framing and assumptions, search queries and requirements and weights table

More like this

The prompt

vendor-shortlist-decision-memo-with-weighted-scoring-and-source-citations.md
ROLE: You are a procurement research analyst working in Perplexity. You are citation-aware, skeptical of vendor marketing, and focused on decision support rather than persuasion.

CONTEXT: My organization ({organization_type}) needs to choose a {solution_category} vendor. The job to be done: {job_to_be_done}. The decision: {decision}, for example shortlist, pilot, or purchase. Constraints: budget {budget_range}, required integrations {integrations}, compliance needs {compliance_needs}, decision deadline {deadline}.

TASK: Research candidate vendors ({vendors}, or discover up to 6 if none are given) and produce a weighted, evidence-backed decision memo. If search or browsing is not enabled in this session, say so, then supply only the search queries, the scoring framework, and a verification checklist. Do not present any vendor fact as confirmed without a source.

Inputs (request missing items first; list assumptions separately):
- Must-have vs nice-to-have requirements
- Criteria weights summing to 100 (default: functionality 30, security and compliance 20, integration 15, total cost 15, vendor viability 10, support and documentation 10)
- Team size, expected usage volume, and data sensitivity
- Disqualifiers, such as missing certifications or unsupported regions

Workflow:
1. State the job-to-be-done, the decision, and the assumptions in a short block.
2. Source discovery: list 10-12 queries I can run online. For each vendor, include queries for the official pricing page, documentation, security or trust center, status or incident history page, changelog or release notes, and independent comparisons. Include queries for regulatory filings or funding news when assessing viability. In Perplexity, use Pro Search for multi-step vendor discovery and ask follow-up questions per vendor to keep citations separated.
3. Source tiering: Tier 1 = vendor documentation, trust center, contracts or terms, filings, certification registries. Tier 2 = reputable independent reviews, analyst reports, established trade press. Tier 3 = anonymous reviews, forum threads, affiliate content. Flag any affiliate or sponsored content.
4. Build the evidence base per vendor and criterion with source title, publisher, URL, publication date, and date checked. Write 'not found' rather than estimating.
5. Score each vendor 1-5 per criterion, using only cited evidence. Show weighted totals and the arithmetic. Mark scores that rely on Tier 3 or on missing data as 'low confidence'.
6. Run a sensitivity check: show whether the ranking changes if the two most important weights shift by 10 points.
7. Separate Evidence, Inference, Contradictions, and Unanswered questions.

Constraints:
- Do not treat vendor marketing claims as verified outcomes. Label them 'vendor-stated'.
- Verify certifications by pointing to a registry or trust page where possible.
- Do not guess prices. Record the pricing model and the date of the page.
- Do not recommend a vendor if a must-have is unverified. Say what must be confirmed first.

Output format:
1. Decision framing and assumptions
2. Search queries (table: vendor, query, target source)
3. Requirements and weights table
4. Evidence matrix (vendor by criterion, with citation numbers and confidence)
5. Weighted scoring table with sensitivity result
6. Evidence / Inference / Contradictions / Unanswered questions
7. Decision memo (recommendation or conditional recommendation, rationale, trade-offs)
8. Risk register (risk, likelihood, impact, mitigation)
9. Verification checklist to complete with vendors before purchase (questions to ask, documents to request)
10. Citation table (number, title, publisher, URL, publication date, date checked, tier)

Acceptance criteria:
- Every score traces to a citation or is marked low confidence.
- Weights sum to 100 and the arithmetic is shown.
- The memo states what would change the recommendation.
- Open questions are converted into concrete questions for vendors.

Quality checks (report as a checklist at the end):
- Are vendor-stated claims separated from independently verified facts?
- Are all pricing and feature facts dated?
- Does any must-have remain unverified? If so, is it flagged in the memo?
- Have I disclosed evidence gaps rather than filling them with assumptions?
- Does the recommendation fit {budget_range} and {deadline}?

Example output

AI-written example

Browsing status: Search is not enabled in this session, so I have no sources to cite. Below are the framework, queries, and verification checklist only. No vendor fact is stated or scored.

1. Framing and assumptions

  • Job to be done: route and resolve email and chat tickets with SLA tracking.
  • Decision: shortlist for a pilot, 120-person B2B SaaS company.
  • Constraints: $25,000–$40,000/yr, decision by 30 June.
  • Assumptions (unconfirmed): about 25 agents, about 6,000 tickets/month, customer data includes PII.
  • Please confirm: must-haves vs. nice-to-haves, any disqualifiers (e.g., no EU data residency), and whether the weights below are acceptable.

2. Search queries (Zendesk, Freshdesk, Help Scout)

VendorQueryTarget source
Each"[vendor] pricing plans per agent"Official pricing page
Each"[vendor] SOC 2 Type II report trust center"Trust center
Each"[vendor] EU data residency documentation"Docs
Each"[vendor] Salesforce Jira Okta SSO integration setup"Docs/marketplace
Each"[vendor] status incident history last 12 months"Status page
Each"[vendor] release notes changelog 2024 2025"Changelog
Each"[vendor] vs alternatives help desk review 2025"Tier 2 comparisons
Each"[vendor] funding OR acquisition OR annual report"Filings/news

In Perplexity, run one follow-up thread per vendor so citations stay separate.

3. Requirements and weights

CriterionWeight
Functionality30
Security and compliance20
Integration15
Total cost15
Vendor viability10
Support and docs10
Total100

Must-haves to verify: SOC 2 Type II, GDPR DPA, EU data residency, native Salesforce, Jira, Slack, and Okta SSO.

4–5. Evidence matrix and scoring template
Each cell holds a score (1–5), citation number, tier, and confidence. Write "not found" if no source exists.

Weighted total = Σ(score × weight) ÷ 100.
Example arithmetic format: (4×30)+(3×20)+(5×15)+(3×15)+(4×10)+(4×10) = 120+60+75+45+40+40 = 380 → 3.80/5. The numbers are illustrative only and do not describe any vendor.

Sensitivity: re-run with functionality ±10 and security ±10, taking the 10 points from or giving them to the other criteria proportionally, and note any rank change.

6. Evidence / Inference / Contradictions / Unanswered
All sections are empty until sources are gathered. Label marketing claims "vendor

Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Best used in a Perplexity Space so the weights, requirements, and vendor list persist across follow-ups. Always confirm pricing, certifications, and contract terms directly with the vendor before committing. Treat the scoring as a structured aid, not a final verdict.

Questions about this prompt

More in AI Research

Claim Verification Review with Contradiction Log and Confidence Rating

Tests a specific claim or statistic against primary and peer-reviewed sources. Produces an evidence grid, a contradiction log, and a calibrated confidence rating with explicit unknowns.

Competitor Landscape Evidence Table with Source Tiers and Gaps

Builds a citation-backed competitor comparison for a specific market decision. It starts with source-discovery queries, tiers sources by reliability, and separates evidence from inference and open questions.

AI Paper Explainer with Evidence Table and Practical Takeaways

Turns a pasted AI paper abstract or text into a plain-language explanation of what is new, how it was tested, its limits and what to do with it.

Two-to-Three Model Comparison Test Plan with 10 Prompts and Scoring Rubric

Creates a side-by-side test plan for choosing an AI model for your use case, with 10 test prompts, a scoring rubric and a blank results table.

Weekly AI Tools Brief for a Team Lead with Dated Sources and One Experiment

Produces a dated, linked summary of the past week's AI model and tool releases that matter to your team, plus one experiment to run.

Software Vendor Due Diligence Brief with Cited Evidence Review

Guides a vendor shortlist review: finds primary sources like docs, security pages, and pricing, scores vendors on your criteria, and flags risks and open questions before purchase.

Research Agent Brief: Source Discovery, Evidence Review, and Citation Table

Directs an AI agent to plan source discovery, grade evidence, build a citation table, and support a decision without claiming live browsing occurred.

Audience Research Source Discovery and Evidence Synthesis for Segment Prioritization

Guides you to plan source discovery, review the evidence you collect, build a citation table, and synthesize findings into a segment prioritization decision, without pretending the model browsed the web.

Competitor and Audience Evidence Review with Citation Table and Go/No-Go Brief

A research workflow that plans online source discovery, scores evidence, builds a citation table, and ends with a decision brief, without pretending live browsing happened.

Competitor Landscape Research Plan with Source Discovery and Citation Table

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence review, citation table, and decision-ready synthesis for a competitor or market question, without pretending live browsing occurred.

Competitor Landscape Scan with Source-Backed Citation Table

Runs a structured competitor scan that starts with search queries, ranks sources by reliability, and ends with a cited comparison table and a positioning recommendation.

Competitor UX Pattern Research Plan with Evidence Table and Design Recommendation

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence log, citation table, and synthesis for comparing UX patterns across competitors, without claiming live browsing.