Salary Counteroffer Email, Call Script and Pushback Replies

Turn your job offer and target number into a polite counteroffer email, phone talking points and replies to the three likeliest pushbacks.

You get: A filled-in template

More like this

The prompt

salary-counteroffer-email-call-script-and-pushback-replies.md
Act as a calm, experienced compensation negotiation coach. My offer details are: {paste offer details}. My target number is: {target number}. Job to be done: help me decide how to ask and say it confidently without damaging the relationship. Rules: be polite and collaborative, with no ultimatums; justify the ask with my value and scope, never with invented competing offers or market data you cannot verify; if base, bonus, equity, benefits or location are missing, ask me one or two short questions first; list your assumptions separately. Output: 1) a short assumptions and gaps list; 2) a counteroffer email under 180 words; 3) six phone talking points; 4) a table of the three most likely pushbacks, each with a suggested reply and a fallback ask such as bonus, review date or extra leave; 5) risks and a walk-away check I should decide before the call; 6) next actions. Check that the numbers are consistent with the offer and the tone stays warm.

Example output

AI-written example

1) Assumptions and gaps

  • Offer: Senior Product Designer, $112,000 base, 10% target bonus, 15 PTO days, hybrid 3 days a week, no sign-on bonus.
  • Target: $124,000 base (+10.7%).
  • Assumed achievements: led a checkout redesign that lifted conversion 9%, and mentored two designers. Swap in your own verified results.
  • Gap: equity and review cycle were not mentioned. No market data is cited.

2) Counteroffer email (about 150 words)

Subject: Senior Product Designer offer

Hi Maya,

Thank you again for the offer. I'm excited about the payments roadmap and working with your team.

Before I accept, I'd like to talk about base salary. The role involves leading design for payments and mentoring two designers. I've done similar work, including a checkout redesign that lifted conversion by 9%. With that scope in mind, would a base of $124,000 be possible?

I'm keen to join and confident we can find a number that works for both sides. I'm free for a quick call Wednesday or Thursday if that's easier.

Warm regards,
Jordan Ellis

3) Phone talking points

  1. Open with thanks and real enthusiasm for the team.
  2. State the ask once: "I'm hoping we can get to $124,000 base."
  3. Link it to scope: payments ownership and mentoring.
  4. Give one proof point, the 9% conversion lift.
  5. Ask: "What flexibility do you have?" Then stay quiet.
  6. Close warmly: "I'd love to make this work."

4) Likely pushbacks

PushbackSuggested replyFallback ask
"$112k is the top of the band.""Understood. Could we look at the total package, since the scope is what I'm weighing?"$6,000 sign-on bonus
"We need to stay fair to current team members.""That makes sense. Could we agree a performance review at six months with a salary adjustment in view?"Six-month review date
"What's the lowest you'd accept?""I'd rather not name a floor. I'm aiming for $124k and open to how we structure it."5 extra PTO days

5) Risks and walk-away check

  • Risk: the offer may not move. Withdrawals are rare when the tone is polite, but possible.
  • Decide before the call: your minimum, for example $118,000 base, or $112,000 plus a sign-on bonus and
Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Use after receiving a written offer and before replying. Paste the offer terms without private details such as home address or ID numbers.

Questions about this prompt

More in Business

Likely Interview Questions with STAR Model Answers from Your CV

Get 8 predicted interview questions for a specific job, each with a STAR model answer built only from facts in your CV.

Live Mock Interviewer That Scores Each Answer 1-5

Run a realistic one-question-at-a-time mock interview for your role and company, with a score and one concrete fix after every answer.

Business Idea Validation Sprint with a $100 Two-Week Test

Turn a business idea and target customer into a ranked list of risky assumptions, five interview questions and a $100 test to run in two weeks.

Competitor Landscape Research Plan with Source Discovery and Citation Table

Builds a source discovery plan, evidence review, citation table, and decision-ready synthesis for a competitor or market question, without pretending live browsing occurred.

Debt Payoff Comparison: Avalanche vs Snowball with Interest Totals

Compare the avalanche and snowball methods on months to debt-free and total interest using your own debts and extra payment, as education only.

Freelance Hourly and Project Rate Calculator with Tax and Admin Math

Calculate a sustainable hourly and project rate from your income target and billable hours, covering tax, unpaid admin time and expenses with the math shown.

Monthly KPI Variance Review with Drivers and Action Plan for Leadership

Converts pasted monthly KPI results and targets into a variance analysis, driver hypotheses, and prioritized actions that a leadership team can decide on in one meeting.

Build a zero-based monthly budget from typed income and spending amounts, flag overspending and get three realistic cuts, with no account access.

Operations Bottleneck Diagnosis and 30-Day Process Fix Plan

Diagnoses where a workflow slows down using your process steps and metrics, then ranks causes and produces a 30-day improvement plan with owners, measures, and risks.

Pricing Change Decision Memo with Scenario Math and Test Plan

Turns current pricing, cost, and customer data into a decision memo comparing hold, adjust, and repackage options, with scenario math, risks, and a controlled pricing test plan.

Salary Negotiation Script With Replies to the Five Most Likely Counteroffers

Builds a negotiation script for a job offer: your anchor number with a reason, word-for-word replies to common pushback, and a walk-away line, using market data you supply.

Side Hustle Matcher Ranked by Cost, Speed and Realism

Get five side hustles matched to your skills and weekly hours, ranked by startup cost, time to first $100 and realism, each with a first step.