Generate Discussion Questions That Build From Recall to Debate for Any Text

You get leveled discussion questions for any text, ordered from recall to evaluation, each with a follow-up probe, likely evidence, and sentence starters for quieter students.

Prompt

Prompt
You are an experienced secondary English teacher who leads text-based class discussions.

Your job: write discussion questions for a text my class is reading, ordered from simple recall up to open debate.

Before writing, ask me these in one message, then wait for my answers:
1. What is the text? Paste it, or give the title and author.
2. What grade or age are the students?
3. How long is the discussion, and roughly how many questions do you want?
4. Is there a theme or skill you want the discussion to build toward?

Rules:
- Use four levels in this order: Recall, Interpret, Analyze, Evaluate. Each level has at least two questions.
- Every question points to a specific moment, line or detail in the text, not the text in general.
- Each question gets one follow-up probe that pushes for evidence or a second viewpoint.
- No question can be answered with yes or no alone. Evaluate questions must have at least two defensible answers.
- Give two sentence starters per level for students who hesitate to speak.

Output format:
For each level: a heading, then a numbered list where each item shows Question, Probe, and Evidence to look for (one line). End each level with Sentence starters.
Finish with one closing debate question and a suggested time split.

End with one line on what you assumed about the text or students, and say clearly if you do not know the text well enough to reference it accurately.

Example output

At a glance45-minute discussion time split by levelGrade 9, "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson
  • Recall: 5 min
  • Interpret: 10 min
  • Analyze: 12 min
  • Evaluate: 13 min
  • Closing debate: 5 min

Example for: Grade 9 English, "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson, 45-minute discussion, building toward the theme of blind tradition.

Level 1: Recall

  1. Question: What do the children do with stones at the start of the story, and how do the adults react?
    Probe: Why might Jackson open with that detail?
    Evidence to look for: Bobby Martin filling his pockets; boys guarding the pile.
  2. Question: What happened to the original lottery box and paraphernalia?
    Probe: What has changed about the ritual, and what has stayed?
    Evidence to look for: Wood chips replaced by paper; the black box is shabby but kept.

Sentence starters: "In the text it says..." / "The first thing I noticed was..."

Level 2: Interpret

  1. Question: What does Tessie's late arrival suggest about her attitude toward the lottery?
    Probe: Does her mood change? When?
    Evidence to look for: Joking with Mr. Summers; "It wasn't fair" after the draw.
  2. Question: What does Old Man Warner mean by "Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon"?
    Probe: Who in the town still believes this?
    Evidence to look for: His reaction to the north village quitting.

Sentence starters: "I think this shows that..." / "This could mean... because..."

Level 3: Analyze

  1. Question: How does Jackson's calm, ordinary tone shape the impact of the ending?
    Probe: Find one sentence that feels normal on first read but dark on second.
    Evidence to look for: Descriptions of the sunny morning and casual chatter.
  2. Question: Why does Tessie protest only after her family is chosen?
    Probe: What does that say about the other villagers?
    Evidence to look for: Her earlier cheerfulness; neighbors urging her to "be a good sport."

Sentence starters: "The author uses... to..." / "This connects to... because..."

Level 4: Evaluate

  1. Question: Who is most responsible for the stoning: Mr. Summers, Old Man Warner, or the whole village?
    Probe: Would your answer change if one person had refused?
    Evidence to look for: Summers running the draw; Warner's defense; the crowd closing in.
  2. Question: Is following a tradition ever a good enough reason on its own?
    Probe: Name a tradition today that someone could defend or challenge the same way.
    Evidence to look for: Warner's "pack of young fools" speech; the villages that stopped.

Sentence starters: "I partly agree with... but..." / "A stronger argument would be..."

Closing Debate Question

Should the villagers who quietly doubt the lottery be judged as harshly as those who defend it?

Suggested Time Split

  • Recall: 5 min
  • Interpret: 10 min
  • Analyze: 12 min
  • Evaluate: 13 min
  • Closing debate: 5 min

Assumption: students have finished the full story once; quoted lines are short and should be checked against your class edition.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Four fixed levels in order make the discussion climb from easy entry points to real argument instead of jumping straight to opinion.
  • Tying every question to a specific moment forces students back to the text and stops vague, general answers.
  • Probes and per-level sentence starters give the teacher a next move and give quiet students a way in.

Use when planning a seminar or class discussion on a story, article, poem or chapter. Have the text or its title, grade level and discussion length ready. Works in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini; paste the text for less-known works.

Common edits

  • Swap the four levels for your school's framework, such as Bloom's six levels or DOK 1-4.
  • Ask for a printable student version with only the questions and sentence starters.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Education