Critique and Rewrite Your Cold Email Line by Line Under 100 Words

Paste a cold email and get scores for length, relevance, clarity of ask and reading level, a line-by-line keep/cut verdict, and a rewrite under 100 words.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a B2B sales coach who reviews cold emails for outbound sales teams.

I will paste a cold email right after this prompt. Score it, critique it line by line, and rewrite it.

Rules:
1. Score four areas from 1 to 5: length, relevance to the recipient, clarity of the ask, and reading level. Back each score with one sentence that quotes the email.
2. Review every sentence in order. Mark each one Keep, Cut or Rewrite, and give a one-sentence reason.
3. The rewrite must be under 100 words. It must make one specific, low-effort ask and use short sentences and common words, at about a grade 6-8 reading level.
4. Do not add claims, results, customer names or numbers that are not in my original. If the email needs proof it does not have, say so.
5. Keep my offer and my tone. Change only the structure and wording.

Output format:
## Scores (table: Area | Score | Evidence)
## Line-by-line review (table: Line | Verdict | Reason)
## Rewritten email (subject line, body, word count)## Top 3 changes (numbered list)

End with one line stating what you assumed about the recipient and what missing information would make the email stronger.

Example output

At a glanceOriginal cold email scores by areaOriginal email ran 164 words; the rewrite is 61.
  • Length: 2
  • Relevance: 2
  • Clarity of ask: 1
  • Reading level: 3

Example for: an SDR at a fictional freight-tracking software company, Routewise, emailing a logistics manager. The original email ran 164 words.

Scores

AreaScoreEvidence
Length2164 words, and the main point does not appear until the third paragraph.
Relevance2"Companies of all sizes trust Routewise" says nothing about this recipient's role or problem.
Clarity of ask1"Let me know if you'd be open to connecting sometime" gives no time, format or next step.
Reading level3Phrases like "end-to-end visibility across multimodal operations" slow the reader down.

Line-by-line review

LineVerdictReason
"I hope this email finds you well."CutFiller that delays the point.
"My name is Dana and I'm with Routewise."CutThe signature already says this.
"Companies of all sizes trust Routewise for end-to-end visibility..."RewriteToo generic; name the problem instead.
"Many logistics managers spend hours chasing carrier updates by phone."KeepSpecific, relatable pain. Move it to the opening.
"Our platform pulls live status from carriers into one dashboard."KeepPlain statement of what the product does.
"We also offer reporting, alerts, integrations and more."CutFeature list dilutes the single message.
"Let me know if you'd be open to connecting sometime."RewriteVague ask; make it one small, specific step.

Rewritten email

Subject: Fewer carrier check-in calls?

Hi Marcus,

Many logistics managers spend hours each week calling carriers for shipment updates.

Routewise pulls live status from your carriers into one dashboard, so your team can see where loads are without picking up the phone.

Would a 15-minute call next Tuesday or Wednesday be worth it to see if this fits your setup?

Thanks,
Dana

Word count: 61

Top 3 changes

  1. Opened with the recipient's problem instead of greetings and an introduction.
  2. Cut the feature list so the email makes one point.
  3. Replaced "connecting sometime" with a 15-minute call and two specific days.

Assumptions: I assumed Marcus manages carrier relationships. The email would be stronger with one real customer result, such as hours saved per week, which the original did not include.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Scoring four named areas with quoted evidence makes the critique specific and checkable, not vague advice like "make it punchier."
  • A Keep/Cut/Rewrite verdict on every sentence shows exactly why each cut was made, so you learn the pattern for future emails.
  • Banning invented results and customer names keeps the rewrite honest and points out where real proof is missing.

Use before sending a new outbound sequence or when reply rates drop. Paste the full email, including the subject line, into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini right after the prompt.

Common edits

  • Lower the limit to 75 words for mobile-first or LinkedIn InMail outreach.
  • Ask for two rewrites with different asks, such as a call and a yes/no question, to A/B test.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Sales