Compare Two Mortgage Loan Estimates Line by Line Before You Choose a Lender

Paste two Loan Estimates and get a side-by-side table of rate, points, fees, cash to close and five-year cost, plus clear questions to send each lender.

You getTable, what drives the difference and bottom line

Prompt

Prompt
Act as an experienced mortgage loan officer who helps home buyers read the standard 3-page US Loan Estimate.

Right after this prompt I will paste two Loan Estimates, labeled Lender A and Lender B. Compare them line by line so I can see which loan actually costs less.

Rules:
1. Use only numbers that appear in the estimates. If a figure is missing or unclear, write "not shown". Do not guess.
2. Separate lender-controlled costs (Section A origination and points, Section B) from taxes, prepaids and escrow, which should be similar across lenders.
3. For five-year cost, use the "In 5 Years" figure on page 3. If it is missing, calculate it and show the math.
4. Flag any difference over $500, and any mismatch in loan amount, term, loan type or lock date that makes the comparison unfair.
5. Write questions in plain words a buyer can paste into an email.

Output format:
1. Table: Item | Lender A | Lender B | Difference. Rows: loan amount, rate, APR, points, origination, Section B, total loan costs, other costs, total closing costs, cash to close, monthly payment, lock expiry, five-year cost.
2. What drives the difference (3-5 bullets, include the points break-even month)
3. Questions for each lender (3-4 each)
4. Bottom line (2-3 sentences)

This is not financial advice; confirm final terms in writing and see a HUD-approved housing counselor if unsure. End by listing assumptions and missing data.

Example output

At a glanceLender A vs Lender B: key loan estimate figures$360,000 30-year fixed loan, estimates issued the same week
ItemLender ALender B
Rate6.625%6.375%
Points$0$3,600 (1 point)
Total closing costs$15,310$18,875
Cash to close$50,310$53,875
Monthly payment (with escrow)$2,915$2,856
Five-year cost$144,190$143,655

Example for: a $400,000 home purchase, $360,000 30-year fixed loan, two Loan Estimates issued the same week.

1. Side-by-Side Comparison

ItemLender ALender BDifference
Loan amount$360,000$360,000$0
Rate6.625%6.375%B 0.25% lower
APR6.71%6.62%B 0.09% lower
Points$0$3,600 (1 point)B +$3,600
Origination$1,295$995A +$300
Section B$2,140$2,100A +$40
Total loan costs (D)$5,890$8,895B +$3,005
Other costs (I)$9,420$9,980B +$560 ⚠️
Total closing costs$15,310$18,875B +$3,565 ⚠️
Cash to close$50,310$53,875B +$3,565 ⚠️
Monthly payment (with escrow)$2,915$2,856B $59 lower
Rate lock expiryJune 14June 28B 14 days longer
Five-year cost ("In 5 Years")$144,190$143,655B $535 lower

2. What Drives the Difference

  • Lender B's lower rate is bought with 1 point ($3,600). That saves $59 a month.
  • Break-even on the extra $3,300 upfront (points minus lower origination) is about month 56, so B only wins if you keep the loan more than about 4.7 years.
  • Lender B's other costs are $560 higher, mostly a larger escrow cushion. This is money you get back, not a fee, but it raises cash to close.
  • Section B fees are nearly identical, so third-party costs are not the deciding factor.
  • Lender A's lock expires two weeks earlier; check this against your closing date.

3. Questions to Ask

Lender A

  • What rate can you offer with 1 point, so I can compare directly with another offer?
  • Can you waive or reduce the $1,295 origination fee?
  • Will the lock cover a closing on June 20, and what does an extension cost?

Lender B

  • What is the rate with zero points?
  • Why is the initial escrow deposit $560 higher than another estimate for the same property?
  • Is the 1 point required, or optional?
  • Are any Section B fees likely to change before closing?

4. Bottom Line

If you expect to sell or refinance within five years, Lender A costs less overall and needs $3,565 less cash at closing. If you plan to stay longer, Lender B saves money after about month 56. Ask both for a zero-point and a one-point quote on the same day to compare fairly.

Assumptions and missing data: Property tax and insurance assumed equal from page 2. Neither estimate shows lender credits. Monthly payments include $610 escrow.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Splitting lender-controlled fees from taxes and escrow shows where lenders truly differ, not just which total is bigger.
  • Using the page 3 "In 5 Years" figure and a points break-even month turns a rate debate into a real cost decision.
  • Flagging mismatched lock dates or loan terms stops you from comparing two loans that aren't actually alike.

Use within a day or two of receiving both Loan Estimates, ideally locked the same day. Paste the full text of each into ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, labeled Lender A and Lender B.

Common edits

  • Add a third Loan Estimate as Lender C and ask for an extra table column.
  • Change the five-year horizon to seven or ten years if you plan to stay longer.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Real Estate