Build a Fair Tenant Screening Checklist with Consistent Pass/Fail Criteria

You get written pass/fail screening criteria, an application-to-decision checklist, and a documentation log that apply the same standards to every rental applicant.

Prompt

Prompt
Act as a property management consultant who sets up fair, consistent tenant screening for small landlords.

Before writing anything, ask me these questions in one message and wait for my answers:
1. Property type, number of units, monthly rent, and city and state or country.
2. Do local rules limit what I can check, such as criminal history, source of income, fees, or credit? Say "not sure" if unknown.
3. Which screening tools I use now.
4. Past tenant problems I want the criteria to address.

Then write a screening policy with these rules:
- Every criterion is objective and measurable (e.g., "gross monthly income at least 2.5x rent"), never "good fit" or "seems reliable".
- Process complete applications in the order received; offer the unit to the first applicant who qualifies.
- Exclude anything tied to federally protected classes and flag where local law may add more, such as source of income.
- Cover reasonable accommodation requests and adverse action notices for denials based on credit reports.
- Give one allowed alternative per criterion, such as a co-signer, offered to everyone equally.

Output format:
1. Criteria table: Criterion | Pass standard | Documents required | Allowed alternative
2. Numbered checklist from application to decision
3. Documentation log table: Date received | Applicant ID | Pass/fail per criterion | Decision | Reason | Notice sent
4. Local rules to verify

End with one line saying this is not legal advice and that a local landlord-tenant attorney or housing agency should review the policy before use.

Example output

Example for: a landlord with a 2-unit duplex in a mid-size Midwest city, $1,400/month rent, using an online credit and eviction report, past issue with late payments.

1. Screening Criteria

CriterionPass standardDocuments requiredAllowed alternative
IncomeCombined gross monthly income at least 2.5x rent ($3,500)2 recent pay stubs, benefit letter, or offer letterCo-signer with income at least 4x rent ($5,600)
CreditNo unpaid rental or utility collections over $500 in past 3 yearsScreening report (applicant authorizes)Additional deposit of half a month's rent ($700), where local law allows
Rental historyNo eviction judgment in past 5 yearsScreening report, prior landlord contactWritten explanation plus co-signer
ApplicationAll adults 18+ submit a complete application and feeSigned form, photo IDNone

2. Checklist: Application to Decision

  1. Post written criteria with the listing and give a copy to every applicant.
  2. Time-stamp each complete application; incomplete ones are not queued.
  3. Run the same screening report for every adult applicant.
  4. Score each criterion pass/fail in the log; no other factors.
  5. If one criterion fails, offer the listed alternative in writing.
  6. Offer the unit to the first fully qualified applicant; give 48 hours to accept.
  7. For credit-based denials, send an adverse action notice naming the reporting agency.
  8. Treat accommodation requests (e.g., an assistance animal in a no-pet unit) separately and respond in writing.
  9. Keep all applications and logs for at least 3 years.

3. Documentation Log

Date receivedApplicant IDIncomeCreditRental historyDecisionReasonNotice sent
Mar 4, 9:12amA-01PassFailPassConditional$820 utility collection; deposit offeredMar 5, email
Mar 4, 2:40pmA-02PassPassPassApproved, pending A-01Second in queueMar 5, email

4. Local Rules to Verify

  • Whether your city or state protects source of income, including housing vouchers.
  • Limits on application fees and security deposit size.
  • Rules on criminal history screening and lookback periods.
  • Required wording and timing for denial notices.

This is not legal advice; have a local landlord-tenant attorney or fair housing agency review this policy before you use it.

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Asking about location and local limits first keeps the criteria from including checks your area restricts.
  • Forcing measurable pass standards removes gut-feel judgments that create discrimination risk.
  • The time-stamped log records why each decision was made, which is the evidence you need if a denial is challenged.

Use before listing a vacancy in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. Have your rent amount, location, unit count, and the screening services you use ready; answer the four questions it asks.

Common edits

  • Change the income multiple or lookback periods to match your market and risk tolerance.
  • Ask for a one-page applicant-facing version of the criteria to post with your listing.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Real Estate