Audit an Underperforming Ad and Rewrite It With a Reason for Every Change

Get a pass/fail audit of your pasted ad on four copy checks, two rewrites that test different angles, and a change log tying every edit to a failed check.

You getAudit table, rewrite A and Rewrite B and change log

Prompt

Prompt
You are a direct-response copywriter who audits paid ads for a living.

I will paste an underperforming ad right after this message (headline, body, call to action, and any results I have). If I haven't said the platform, the target customer, or the goal of the ad, ask me up to 3 short numbered questions in one message and wait for my answers.

Then audit the ad and rewrite it.

Rules:
1. Score the ad Pass, Weak, or Fail on four checks: specific audience, single promise, concrete benefit, clear next step. Quote the exact words behind each score.
2. Every change in the rewrite must name the check it fixes. No change without a reason.
3. Use only claims, prices, and facts I give you. Do not add statistics, reviews, or guarantees.
4. Respect the platform's character limits and state which limits you used.
5. Write two rewrites that test different angles, not two wordings of the same idea.

Output format:
1. Audit table: Check | Score | Evidence (quoted) | Fix
2. Rewrite A and Rewrite B, each with headline, body, call to action, and the angle in one line
3. Change log: Original line → New line → Check fixed
4. The one test to run first and the metric to watch

End with one line naming any assumption you made or missing information that would change the rewrite.

Example output

At a glanceTwo rewrite angles for the Brightlane adBoth fix the four failed or weak copy checks
ItemRewrite ARewrite B
AngleFear of the quarterly tax billGet time back for client work
HeadlineFreelance Designer? Taxes Handled.Design More, Do Books Never
Headline length34 chars27 chars
OfferFlat $95/month, estimate every quarterFlat $95/month, tax estimates included
CTABook a free 15-min callSee how it works

Example for: Brightlane Bookkeeping, a Facebook ad aimed at freelance designers, 0.4% CTR, offer is a flat $95/month with quarterly tax estimates included.

Original ad: Headline "Bookkeeping Made Easy." Body "We offer professional bookkeeping, tax prep, payroll and more for businesses of all sizes. Our expert team is here to help you grow. Contact us today!" Button: Learn More.

1. Audit

CheckScoreEvidence (quoted)Fix
Specific audienceFail"businesses of all sizes"Name freelance designers directly
Single promiseFail"bookkeeping, tax prep, payroll and more"Lead with one job: quarterly taxes handled
Concrete benefitWeak"help you grow"Swap for the $95 flat fee and included tax estimates
Clear next stepWeak"Contact us today!" + Learn MoreSay what happens after the click

2. Rewrites

Rewrite A — Angle: fear of the quarterly tax bill

  • Headline: Freelance Designer? Taxes Handled. (34 chars)
  • Body: Stop guessing your quarterly tax payment. We track your income and send your estimate every quarter, for a flat $95/month.
  • CTA: Book a free 15-min call

Rewrite B — Angle: get time back for client work

  • Headline: Design More, Do Books Never (27 chars)
  • Body: Freelance designers: hand us your receipts and invoices. Flat $95/month, quarterly tax estimates included. You stay on client work.
  • CTA: See how it works

3. Change log

Original lineNew lineCheck fixed
"businesses of all sizes""Freelance designers"Specific audience
"bookkeeping, tax prep, payroll and more""send your estimate every quarter"Single promise
"help you grow""flat $95/month"Concrete benefit
"Contact us today!""Book a free 15-min call"Clear next step
"Bookkeeping Made Easy""Freelance Designer? Taxes Handled."Specific audience, single promise

Limits used: Meta headline 40 characters, primary text about 125 characters before "See more."

4. First test

Run A against B with the same audience and budget for 7 days or 2,000 impressions each. Watch link CTR first (target: above 1%), then cost per booked call.

Assumption: the free 15-minute call exists; if not, change the CTA to "Get started for $95/month."

Written by AI from this prompt. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Why this works

  • Four named checks turn vague feedback into a pass/fail score you can verify against quoted lines.
  • Requiring a reason for every change stops cosmetic rewrites and shows what actually broke.
  • Two different angles give a real A/B test instead of two near-identical ads.

Use when an ad gets low clicks or conversions. Paste the full ad text, platform, audience, and any numbers you have into ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. Include real prices or offers so the rewrite can use them.

Common edits

  • Add a fifth check, such as brand voice or compliance with platform ad policies.
  • Ask for three headline variants per rewrite for Google Responsive Search Ads.

Prompt details

By
Prompts-GPT editors
Published

Did this prompt work?

Keep exploring

More in Marketing