Above-the-Fold Landing Page Critique with 3 Headline, Subhead, and CTA Variants

Critiques landing page copy for clarity and conversion, then rewrites the headline, subhead, and CTA in three distinct variants.

You get: A text answer

More like this

The prompt

above-the-fold-landing-page-critique-with-3-headline-subhead-and-cta-variants.md
You are a conversion copywriter reviewing a founder's landing page. Target customer: {target customer}. Page copy: {paste your landing page copy here}. If the offer, price, or main action is unclear from the copy, ask me one or two short questions first. Job: judge whether a visitor from the target customer would understand within five seconds what this is, who it is for, why it matters, and what to do next. Rules: quote the exact lines you critique; use only claims in the copy and never invent proof, numbers, or testimonials; keep headlines under 12 words; make each CTA name the outcome, not just 'Submit'. Output: 1) Assumptions. 2) Critique table with columns Element, Problem, Fix, Priority. 3) Three variants, each with headline, subhead, CTA, and the angle it tests (outcome, pain, or proof). 4) Check that each variant is specific, honest, and consistent with the copy. 5) Risks and missing proof to add, and one A/B test to run first.

Example output

AI-written example

Assumptions

  • Target customer: freelance designers who invoice clients manually and dislike chasing late payments.
  • The product is Tallybird, an invoicing tool. The copy mentions automatic reminders, card and bank payments, and a free plan for up to 3 clients, then $12/month.
  • The primary action is signing up for the free plan.

Critique

ElementProblemFixPriority
Headline: "The Future of Billing Is Here"Vague. It doesn't say what the product is or who it's for.Name the job (invoicing) and the benefit (getting paid).High
Subhead: "Our AI-powered platform streamlines your financial workflows."Jargon. "AI" and "workflows" are never explained, and nothing in the copy supports them.Replace with the concrete features: reminders, card and bank payments.High
CTA: "Get Started"Doesn't say what happens next or that it's free.Name the outcome and the free plan.High
"400+ freelancers send invoices with Tallybird"Strong proof, but buried below the fold.Move it near the CTA.Medium
"Free for up to 3 clients, then $12/month"Pricing is clear but hidden in the footer.Add a short "Free for up to 3 clients" line under the CTA.Medium

Variants

A: Outcome

  • Headline: Send invoices that get you paid on time
  • Subhead: Accept cards and bank transfers, and let automatic reminders follow up for you.
  • CTA: Create my first free invoice
  • Tests: the outcome angle.

B: Pain

  • Headline: Stop chasing clients for payment
  • Subhead: Tallybird sends the reminders and takes card or bank payments, so you can get back to design.
  • CTA: Automate my reminders, free
  • Tests: the pain angle.

C: Proof

  • Headline: 400+ freelancers use Tallybird to get paid
  • Subhead: Send invoices, accept cards and bank transfers, and automate reminders. Free for up to 3 clients.
  • CTA: Join free, no card needed
  • Tests: the proof angle.

Check

  • All three variants use only claims from the copy: reminders, card and bank payments, the free tier, and "400+".
  • "On time" in A is framed as a goal, not a guarantee. Soften it further if legal or support wants.
  • C's "no card needed" appears nowhere in the copy, so confirm it's true or change the CTA to "Join free."
  • None of the variants use "AI" because the copy doesn't explain it.

Risks and missing proof

  • Add context to "400+": a date, or a source such as "as of this month."
  • Add one real testimonial from a freelancer, with permission.
  • State clearly what a client sees when they pay, ideally with a screenshot.
  • Confirm that "on
Generated from this prompt by AI. Your results will vary.

Tips and common edits

Use when your page gets traffic but few sign-ups. Paste the above-the-fold copy plus the sections below it, and replace the target customer with a specific role or situation.

Questions about this prompt

More in Marketing

LinkedIn Post from a Work Lesson, No Engagement Bait

Turns a work story or lesson into a LinkedIn post with a strong first line, short paragraphs, and one clear takeaway.

Competitor and Audience Evidence Review with Citation Table and Go/No-Go Brief

A research workflow that plans online source discovery, scores evidence, builds a citation table, and ends with a decision brief, without pretending live browsing happened.

Competitor Homepage vs Your Positioning: Overlap, White Space, and a Sharper Line

Compares competitor homepage copy with your positioning to map overlap, find unclaimed angles, and propose one sharper differentiating line.

Landing Page Hero Copy in Five Angles With a Test Plan

Writes five versions of the headline, subheadline and button for the top of your landing page, each from a different angle, plus which two to A/B test first and why.

Turns pasted links and notes into a newsletter issue with a hooking intro, three takeaway sections, and one call to action.

Onboarding Email Sequence Audit and Rewrite Around One Activation Event

Audits an existing or planned onboarding email flow, then rewrites it around a single activation event with segmentation, timing, copy, and a measurement plan.

Positioning Statement and Messaging Hierarchy for a Product Launch

Turns product facts, audience insight, and competitor context into a positioning statement, messaging hierarchy, and proof map so a team can approve one launch angle.

Repurpose One Article into 10 Native Posts Across Four Channels

Turns one blog post or article into 10 channel-native pieces for LinkedIn, X, Instagram carousel, and newsletter.

SEO-Friendly Etsy or Gumroad Listing with 13 Tags and FAQ

Produces a complete Etsy or Gumroad listing for a digital or handmade product, with title, 13 tags, description, and FAQ.

Customer Review Mining: Personas, Jobs-to-Be-Done, Objections and Verbatim Copy Phrases

Turns pasted customer reviews into evidence-based personas, jobs-to-be-done, objections and a bank of exact customer phrases ready to reuse in copy.

LinkedIn Headline and About Rewrite Around Measurable Results

Rewrites your LinkedIn About section around measurable achievements for a target role and offers three headline options.

Meta Title and Description Variants: 5 Click-Angle Pairs Within Limits

Writes 5 meta title and description pairs within character limits, each using a different angle to earn the click.